Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare


Rating historyNumber of reviews
Nov 2007
Dec 2007
Jan 2008
Feb 2008
Mar 2008
Apr 2008
May 2008
Jun 2008
Jul 2008
Aug 2008
Sep 2008
Oct 2008


How it sucks

click term for excerpts - most relevant excerpts first
We're not at photorealism yet though, so some images are a little bit off in terms of shading (especially in the intro movie) and characters' faces are a bit cartoonish, but this is not really an issue - after all it's only a game and the characters' faces aren't really that much of an issue when you're hopefully going to kill most characters while they're a hundred yards or more away. The game experience is very fast-paced and the difficulty is about the same as CoD3, but in this game the save points seem to be much closer together so we don't have the same frustrations of nearly getting through a level and then having to go waaay back if we get killed. The developers have done an excellent job here - I wish the people who made Rainbow Six Vegas had instituted a save point system as good as the one in this game - that would have stopped me from throwing that game's disc across the room in frustration and vowing never to buy another Rainbow Six game.
12 months ago @ Amazon
I am stuck on the second level of this game (Marine Sgt Paul Jackson) where the game freezes 100% of the time within one area of the game. I have restarted the game for days and dozens of times and the game freezes at about the same physical point in the game all the time. I can approach the block from the left, center, or flanking right and it freezes an approximately the same boundary point.
10 months ago @ Amazon
well i purchased the game and was not impressed with the graphics or controls. i refuse to pay for xbox live when pc is free so i purchased the pc version and maxed out the graphics and resolution and it like a different game. this version ruins the experience get it for pc the 360 version is a joke
12 months ago @ Amazon
One complaint I have, and it's not really a complaint, but rather a preference, is that I think it would be much better if bodily injury caused the same consequences as in real life. If I get shot by a sniper, or lit up by an AK, I should be dead. Yes, that would make the game that much more difficult, but then I think it would make it that much more interesting too because you would really have to think through your strategy.
12 months ago @ Amazon
Really, what's the sense in giving a player in Team Deathmatch a higher rating for having 10 kills but 25 deaths than a player who had 8 kills and 0 deaths? (I realize there are other game types that reward persistent survival -- but that doesn't explain why Team Deathmatch runs the way it does.) I don't mean to imply that the game favors brain-dead button-mashing -- it doesn't -- but it does severely favor one style of play, which limits the breadth of its appeal. All that said, the game's not exactly worthless.
10 months ago @ Amazon
You have the "throw the grenade back" mechanic in this game (was it in other COD games?) which can be really fun, but also sometimes a bit frustrating, because you can be killed by grenades that do not show up on your "grenade indicator" from time to time. It happens, but it's not so frustrating you want to chuck the controller. You just groan or yell, deal with it, and respawn again.
10 months ago @ Amazon
I tend to hate voice chat, but it can be useful when it's not being used by 12-year-olds to insult your intelligence or parentage. Split-screen is present, but, as usual in the age of online gaming, suffers from overlarge maps. There's a nice variation in weapons (though, it would seem, not the full selection that's in the SP game, which is kind of annoying), but differentiation between weapons is mostly limited to the sniper kits.
11 months ago @ Amazon
The one problem I have with the matchmaking is that it seems to not really care about rank. It just finds open games and throws you in regardless of the fact that you're level 1 fighting level 42's; the system balances the teams out but it doesn't make a terrible amount of sense to me. However, this is not enough to detract a star or even to mar the shine of the game.
10 months ago @ Amazon
If you enjoy getting picked off by an unseen enemy, never even having a chance to fire back, if your game is to find some hidden perch, lie in the prone position and wait for some poor soul to walk in front of your crosshairs, if you loved COD2 because it rewarded your camp/sniping by making the sniper rifle far and away the most effective gun, if you were disappointed when COD3 made the sniper rifle's scope, smaller, cloudier and more difficult to aim, then you will love COD4 because Infinity Ward has put you back on top. In an apparent fit of spitefulness for being snubbed on COD3, Infinity Ward has reversed all of the major improvements made by Treyarch in COD3, taking the franchise back two big steps.
12 months ago @ Amazon
I really mean that, and I've played the majority of FPS games on consoles especially, since around Wolfenstein 3d. CoD3 was a bit of a disappointment and was just lacking in areas, Trearch tried to make the Multiplayer experience a huge deal, but it lacked structure, and Ranked games were a bitch to get into. CoD2 thrived in more close range environments in my opinion.
10 months ago @ Amazon
I picked up the latest installment on the day of its release, but I failed to notice that it is rated "M" for mature, as opposed to "T" as were the previous installments. The rating is appropriate, so much so that I found the game totally inappropriate for a 13 year old. Islamic extremists, abduction, rendition, nuclear terror attacks and the like may be, unfortunately, a reality of today's world; however, I have no intention of simulating them in my family room.
10 months ago @ Amazon
The story of course stretches reality just a bit, but no more than your average action film, and the locations and situations you get into are all pretty cool. There weren't any parts I didn't like until the last level where I felt like I was just playing some average shooter instead of a Call of Duty game, mostly because the fighting was reduced to running through corridors shooting from the hip pretty much at all times and throwing grenades when enemies got too blocked up. I guess I could have slowed down and played it more precisely, but the run and gun was what was working and anyway in the first half of this there was a time limit to get to a certain location.
11 months ago @ Amazon
-One example is from "Sins of The Father" level. When trying to chase down Imran Zakhaev's son (when you reach the street, after the junk yard) Activision stops you from running at full speed to catch Zakhaev's son. This is unbelievably frustrating.
10 months ago @ Amazon
I'm currently on military deployment overseas, and after I bought this game a couple of months ago, it has been running non-stop in the break room, and Halo2 2/ 3 no longer gets any playtime. In fact, after playing thru CoD4 and then taking a shot at Halo 3, couldn't believe how poor the graphics were on Halo 3 comparatively. The troops can't get enough of CoD4 now, both single player and multi-player.
10 months ago @ Amazon
Tried to return or exchange with Hubbagames. No response from that company at all. Got the game from another company.
10 months ago @ Amazon
My only complaint is that it seems buggy. The game has locked up on me 10 or so times in the past week. I think the freezes are related to Xbox live being overwhelmed with traffic, because on other nights the game plays just fine.
10 months ago @ Amazon
After seeing all the 5-star reviews I've decided perhaps a little level-headedness is in order to offset the rave reviews from folks who seem to be unable to see anything wrong with this game. No doubt that very statement (and this review's title) will garner a few 'unhelpful' votes, but what the heck, I'm doing this to help folks, not to be popular. Now don't get me wrong - I like the game very much, BUT I feel that a review has to point out potential drawbacks with a game if it's to be any use to readers.
12 months ago @ Amazon
I'm sorry, but even with the modernizing that's been done - its the same game as Call of Duty 2 (and 3 for that matter - which they seem to be intent on mocking). The moment it really hit was when I heard the oft shouted "Enemies behind those crates over there" line that was repeated over and over again in CoD2. It is essentially the same game.
12 months ago @ Amazon
The missions are well scripted (much to the same degree that the missions in Halo 3 or other Call of Duty games are well scripted), the story is well told and missions range from easy to fun to challenging without getting to terribly annoying. I ran through the game on Hardened difficulty and really got stuck in only a couple of places where I spent ungodly amounts of reloads attempting to accomplish the mission.
11 months ago @ Amazon
I'm sure this is a fun game but seeing as I bought it for the wrong gaming console I had to return it. However, Hubbagames was very prompt in letting me return the game and were very helpfull!
9 months ago @ Amazon

How it doesn't

click term for excerpts - most relevant excerpts first
After some intense nights of multiplayer action and brief trek through the single player, I can say this game is the best FPS multiplayer game on the market. The graphics in this game are some of best yet seen on any system, including PC. This is one of those games that when you see it, you'll definitely say "Wow." The game runs at a rock solid 60 fps and has some fantastic lighting and particle effects.
12 months ago @ Amazon
Ok, so Halo 3 was incredible (so exclude that from my review)... That aside, Call of Duty 4 has without a doubt the best graphics, gameplay, sound, voice acting and emotional storytelling I've ever seen in an FPS. Much of the action will have you completely glued to your seat, (especially the stealth levels in the nuked city.) This game has incredible controls as well, making the experience feel completely natural.
10 months ago @ Amazon
It's worth playing through and the story is really tight. The bottom line is that multi console owners can rejoice because there is a game across the board that shines on any of the systems you own and this is without a doubt one of the best games for the dollar. Don't even fret about picking this up if you are into FPS as this is one of the best ones to date and has raised the bar on what a good military FPS is all about.
12 months ago @ Amazon
I was an avid Gears of War player and then I got Call of Duty 4 and Gears got benched. You have a great choice of weapons when you advance, you get access to more of those weapons and perks. All in all, I have to say this is one of the absolute best shooter games out there and the multiplayer is awesome!
9 months ago @ Amazon
Having played a variety of games across the board, from Pitfall to pacman to Lost World and Bioshock, it is by far THE best first person shooter I have ever played. It's quite probably the best game I have ever played- hands down.
11 months ago @ Amazon
The storyline is great also in the single player mode; the maps look a little different but you truly get a course in how to use the plethora of weaponry! The multiplayer mode blew me away.. I have made a lot a friends (and I admit, some enemies too!) playing this fantastic online game.
8 months ago @ Amazon
This game is truly amazing and is on my top 3 favorite games of all time. The campaign levels are truly unique and realistic and the online multilayer is more addicting than.... well i don't know....
10 months ago @ Amazon
Anyway enough about that, Call of Duty 4 is one of the best games i have played on any xbox console. Graphics are great, game engine is superb, game play is alot of fun, and sound is crisp and loud. There is no vehicle use at all by players, my only complaint.
10 months ago @ Amazon
For the fourth installment of the series once set in World War II, the Call of Duty series moves to the present day (thankfully), and what results is by far the best Call of Duty game to see the light of day yet. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare may very well be one of the best first person shooter's you'll ever play on any system, as it features astounding production values and brilliant multiplayer modes on XBox Live.
12 months ago @ Amazon
I haven't played much of the campaign yet, but the online play is spectacular. The realism is amazing; physics are sweet. I've been playing Halo for the past month and I forgot how much fun a realistic war game can be.
11 months ago @ Amazon
Can't say much more than this game is amazing and addictive! The game is great and the online play is equally as good.
9 months ago @ Amazon
This is really a great game. The storyline is enthralling, the gameplay incredible, the graphics amazing, and the longevity is unbeatable.
10 months ago @ Amazon
The perk system is a great addition to the FPS multiplayer formula. This feature gives people the option to customize their soldier to have certain special abilites during the battle. Some may want to create a sniper who is fast and can't be detected.
12 months ago @ Amazon
The missions are well thought out and demanding of your character so you really feel like you're important to the game rather than just following along. The weapons are great and the system they have set up for the aiming comes in handy for necessary quick firing/killing of enemies. Definitely a must have game if you love shooter games!
9 months ago @ Amazon
By far, one of the best FPS ever made. Single player missions are insanely realistic with the best AI I've seen in a video game yet. It gets your heart pumping.
12 months ago @ Amazon
the arsenal is so vast that everyone can get the gun of their choice and mod it!!! The Mp gameplay can get so frantic sometimes you'll even wonder if that's what the real stuff feels like (without dying litteraly). prestige mode is anther nice bonus...
9 months ago @ Amazon
Nothing different here. In online play, you can put several rounds into your enemy's chest without much happening. And if you ever actually get hurt -- by having an M16 round pass through your carotid artery let's say -- just find some cover and wait a few seconds: all better!
10 months ago @ Amazon
Graphics - arguably the best on any console, period. I give it the nod over Gears of War and BioShock - this is the best looking game I have ever played, and it runs (with all the chaos going on) at a smooth 60 frames per second is 1080P HD glory. The word gets thrown around alot with these newer systems, but this game is truly Photo-Realistic.
12 months ago @ Amazon
I have never made a better decision in my life! This game kicked me on my face, punched me, and shot me in the knees! The game is absolutely beautiful and the gameplay is absolutely flawless!
12 months ago @ Amazon
Anyways the game is great one of the best games of the year I personaly like it better than Halo 3.. If you like first person shooters you will love this..
12 months ago @ Amazon